Caleb hunted with his family growing up, and also participated in recreational shooting.
At some point while he was young, Caleb most likely participated in Journey to the Heart, a Christian retreat for teens and young adults to spend time focused on God.
Along with his siblings, Caleb was homeschooled in the Institute of Basic Life Principles program and attended the yearly conferences in Big Sandy, Texas.
Caleb married Kasey Noel Goodwin on July 7, 2018.
The couple has two children.
Their first child, daughter Erin, was born on June 10, 2019.
Their second child, son Kingston Nathaniel, was born on February 9, 2021.
Caleb was the groomsman at his brother Benjamin's wedding to Bethany Meckle on November 20, 2021.